World-Wide Reach - Strong Local Presence!

PRESS RELEASE: Prepared Remarks of Richard Cordray, Director, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

credit lawsuits
CFPB logo

FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE:
February 16, 2017

CONTACT:
Office of Communications
Tel: (202) 435-7170

Prepared Remarks of Richard Cordray

Director, Consumer Financial Protection Bureau

Alternative Data Field Hearing

Charleston, W.Va.

February 16, 2017

Thank you for joining us. I am glad to be in Charleston as we explore some new frontiers for consumer access to credit. As many of you know, the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is the single federal agency with the sole mission of protecting consumers in the financial marketplace. We are working to ensure that consumers can gain access to financial products and services that are fair, transparent, and competitive. In this spirit, we continue to encourage consumer-friendly innovation, such as through our Project Catalyst. So today we are announcing a Request for Information about unconventional sources of information, new ways to analyze this data, and how new technologies can help in assessing people’s creditworthiness. We want to learn more about whether this kind of alternative data could open up greater access to credit for many Americans who are currently stranded outside the mainstream credit system. We also want to understand how market participants are, or could be, mitigating certain risks to consumers that may arise from these innovations.

Let us begin by reviewing how our mainstream credit system generally works. Until the rise of the modern credit reporting industry, many loans were made based on personal relationships of long standing that develop between creditors and their customers. Someone who knows all about your personal financial story – including your way of making a living, your accumulated wealth, your spending habits, and your family background – has an excellent vantage point for deciding whether it is a good risk to extend credit to you. Based on everything they know about you, they can size up your creditworthiness, including any collateral you may be able to post as security. Thus they can make a pretty careful determination as to whether they are likely to recover what they decide to lend you.

Although this framework still describes some fairly vigorous modes of local lending in this country, particularly at community banks or credit unions, we have also developed another credit framework. It uses automated underwriting systems and is built on extensive data about people’s credit histories and algorithms for analyzing that data. This newer approach reflects changes in our society, such as increased mobility and the growth of national banks and mono-line financial firms. These companies are not in the same position to know all the detailed history of local communities and individual customers at a personal level. This approach also reflects new technological capabilities that can mine mountains of data and determine mathematically which elements are most closely correlated with future performance. To get a loan under this more automated framework, a consumer typically needs a credit score.

An individual credit score is fashioned from the information contained in individual files that are managed by nationwide credit reporting companies. This is a product of the modern era, now greatly bolstered by computerized databases. Each file, known as a credit report, tells the story of a consumer’s credit history and current credit usage – at least what can be known from the information in the file. It records the size and type of loans made to the consumer, what is owed, how much credit is available, and whether prior debts were paid on time. It may list personal loans and car loans, credit card balances, student loans, and mortgages. It may also note unpaid bills in debt collection and list court judgments, liens, or bankruptcies. This credit history is then used to determine how likely consumers are to repay existing debts and to gauge the prospects for repayment of any new debts they may take on.

Some of the limitations of this system derive from historical and contingent circumstances. For example, consumers often try just as hard to meet their monthly rent payments as they do their monthly mortgage payments, but rent is often omitted from credit files, unlike a mortgage payment. This may be because rent is not typically viewed as “credit.”  Or it may be because mortgage loans are made by banks and financial companies that have mechanisms for keeping records of them, which results in more regular categories of reportable data. By contrast, rents are collected by millions of landlords scattered all over the country and data on those payments is not collected in any systematic way. To take another example, debt collectors often report data on the debts they are collecting – including debts arising from unpaid medical bills – but the billers themselves, such as medical providers, do not report such information. Credit files thus may include information about bills you failed to pay, but not about all the bills you did pay.

In automated underwriting systems – and even in many manual underwriting systems – decisions to grant credit and set interest rates on loans are based on credit scores to a large degree. These familiar three-digit scores are drawn from the information contained in individual credit files. As such, credit scores play a central role in the financial lives of American consumers. They can determine whether people will be granted credit at all, or the terms and conditions for doing so, including the interest rate. The availability of credit scores – and the accuracy and completeness of the underlying data – have thus become increasingly important to almost all Americans.

***

Unfortunately, for many consumers with a limited or non-existent credit history, a credit score is out of reach. The Consumer Bureau has run the numbers and estimates that 26 million Americans are “credit invisible,” meaning they have no credit history at all. Under the most widely used scoring models, another 19 million people have credit histories that are too limited or have been inactive for too long to generate a credit score. Here in West Virginia, nearly 180,000 residents are “credit invisible.” And nearly 130,000 residents have too little credit history or histories that are too inactive to have a credit score. Add it up, and about one-in-five adults here in the Mountain State are hampered in their financial lives by the lack of a credit score. The same story can be told virtually anywhere in the country, since 45 million adults fall into this category nationwide.

People with little or no credit history, or who lack a credit score, have fewer opportunities to borrow money in order to build a future and any credit that is available usually costs more. That only deepens their economic vulnerability. Among them are those living in lower-income neighborhoods, young people just starting out in life, and many who are recently widowed or divorced and have not yet built sufficient credit history on their own. Many people without credit records or credit scores work hard and strive to pay their bills on time. They may live paycheck to paycheck, straining to make ends meet. They often are caught in a Catch-22, unable to get credit because they have not had credit before. They cannot seize meaningful opportunities, such as borrowing to start a business or buy a house.

For these consumers, the use of unconventional sources of information, called “alternative data,” may allow them to build a credit history and gain access to credit. Alternative data may draw from sources such as rent or utility payments. These obligations may not qualify under more traditional definitions of “credit” and as a result would not be factored into the credit decisioning process. Alternative data may also draw from electronic transactions such as deposits, withdrawals, or transfers from a checking account. And it can encompass the kinds of information that relationship lenders typically know as a matter of course, such as the consumer’s occupation, educational attainment, and various other personal accomplishments. New forms of alternative data may come from sources that never existed before, such as the way we use our mobile phones or the Internet. By filling in more details of a consumer’s financial life, this information may paint a broader and more accurate picture of their creditworthiness. Adding this kind of alternative data into the mix thus holds out the promise of opening up credit for millions of additional consumers.

Alternative data holds out further promise as well. Credit scores, by their very nature, are backward-looking indicators. Consumers who experience a financial hardship – such as the loss of a job or a large medical expense – may fall behind in making credit payments. This may tag them with a low credit score long after their financial situation has turned around. Alternative data may help lenders identify more precisely, from those who currently carry “subprime” credit scores, a substantial subset of consumers who are, in fact, good credit risks. These people should not be held back simply by their retrospective credit score.

The Request for Information we are issuing today looks into the pros and cons of the use of these unconventional sources of information. We are examining what data are already available for use today, and looking into what the future may hold as technologies evolve. We are seeking to study how these data are being gathered and analyzed in underwriting models now used by banks and other financial companies, including fintech companies. And we are seeking to better understand how these models and modeling techniques are evolving.

***

This Request for Information focuses on four main issues. First, it looks at the potential risks and benefits for consumers of using this additional information to better assess their likelihood of repaying a loan. Second, it looks at how introducing new alternative data sources into the credit decisioning process might add to its complexity. Among other things, we want to find out if this will make credit decisions more difficult for people to understand and thus make it harder for them to control their financial lives. Third, the Request for Information looks at how the use and interpretation of these data may affect privacy and transparency. And finally, it looks at whether reliance on some types of alternative data could result in discrimination, whether inadvertent or otherwise, against certain consumers.

Let me start with access to credit. As I mentioned, a key question for the Consumer Bureau is how people without a credit score can begin building a credit history. We want to learn more about how we could promote the responsible use of alternative data, even as we continue to protect consumers’ interests. For instance, someone with no credit history might nonetheless be quite reliable in paying their cell phone bill or their rent on time. Or they may have a history of checking account deposits and have made good use of a debit card. This might make them a viable credit risk. We know that some lenders will not loan money to consumers with a credit score that is less than, say, 620. But they might do so if alternative data suggest that a particular consumer with such a score would be less likely to default on the loan.

This leads us to the second issue. Even as alternative data may shed more light on a consumer’s creditworthiness, the sheer volume of new data that may be streaming into the system could have other effects. On the one hand, new analytical methods based on unconventional information could produce a faster, less complicated application process, with lower operating costs for lenders and lower loan costs for borrowers. On the other hand, the accumulation of more and more alternative data could create a tangle of information that is harder for people to understand and unravel. The credit process can already be somewhat murky. So we want to learn whether folding in alternative data could complicate the decisions facing consumers. The harder it is for consumers to understand their credit record or whether they are likely to qualify for certain loans, the harder it will be for them to master their finances. This same complexity could also burden lenders who must explain adverse credit decisions to consumers. And it may bog down financial educators and counselors who are trying to help people understand their credit standing and take more control of their financial lives.

The third issue we are raising today concerns how alternative data is shared, by and to whom, and whether these interactions are safe and secure. We want to know whether this information is reliable and whether its use is transparent to consumers. Some consumers may not even know that the information was collected and shared, let alone how it may be used in the credit process. We are also exploring whether some information is more prone to errors because it was collected under weaker standards in place at the time. Another question is whether consumers can correct any mistakes that turn up. As part of our inquiry, we are looking into how the credit reporting laws may apply to these and other issues.

And finally, we are looking into how this information, even if entirely accurate, may be applied or interpreted. If the use and analysis of alternative data leads to certain consumers being needlessly penalized, we want to know that. For example, some newer underwriting algorithms use measures of residential stability. These measures may help predict creditworthiness and may identify consumers who make their rent payments on time.  Yet members of the military are required to move frequently as their duty stations change. As a result, this measure could hinder access to credit for servicemembers, even if they are, in fact, a good credit risk. Other data may be strongly correlated with characteristics such as race or gender, which could enable lenders to do indirectly what they are forbidden from doing directly: drawing conclusions about whether to make a loan based on a person’s race, gender, or other prohibited categories. Similarly, data tied to a consumer’s place on the economic ladder may hinder those trying to climb it. This may be especially true for those who are already struggling financially and facing a system that is full of obstacles. So we are looking into how fair lending laws might apply to these and other issues.

***

As we consider how the risks of alternative data may give rise to the potential for discrimination, I want to pause for a moment and make clear our intentions with this Request for Information. The fair lending laws are designed to promote equal access to credit for all Americans, without regard to race, sex, ethnic background, or a variety of other personal characteristics. The reason for these laws is to eliminate such credit discrimination in the financial marketplace. But if fair lending concerns cast a large enough shadow, they may prevent people from considering and using alternative data that might open up more credit for minority and underserved consumers. This could interfere with progress for the very people these laws are intended to protect.

Equal access to credit means even more if overall access to credit is expanded and not constrained by lingering uncertainty about how regulators intend to apply fair lending laws. So we have crafted this Request for Information to help us better understand whether and how such uncertainty may be hindering credit access for disadvantaged populations. We also want to learn more about how the Consumer Bureau might reduce that uncertainty while holding fast to the anti-discrimination principles that are the cornerstones of federal law. That would help market participants go about their business with more confidence that they can better assess the creditworthiness of particular consumers without running afoul of legal requirements. In short, we see alternative data as holding out the promise to benefit the very populations that may be most disadvantaged by excessive reliance on traditional credit reports and credit scores. And we are committed to having a full and frank discussion about how we can minimize the risks and maximize the potential benefits.

***

With the Request for Information we are issuing today, the Consumer Bureau invites all who are interested in these developments to share their views on this rapidly evolving aspect of financial services. We strongly encourage affordable, responsible lending to more people who may already be deserving of the opportunities that credit can bring to their lives. At the same time, we want to make sure that all lenders are playing by the same rules. This evenhanded oversight both protects consumers and ensures a level playing field for the financial industry. And it applies to both big banks and small startups. We want to learn more about how the use of this data affects consumers and how it is being analyzed and interpreted. And we want to know whether it can help more of our neighbors gain control of their financial destinies, enjoy more options, and achieve their own vision of the American dream. Thank you.

###

The Consumer Financial Protection Bureau is a 21st century agency that helps consumer finance markets work by making rules more effective, by consistently and fairly enforcing those rules, and by empowering consumers to take more control over their economic lives. For more information, visit consumerfinance.gov.

Subscribe!

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 3,740 other subscribers

Upcoming Live Music

No shows booked at the moment.

Featured: Guitarist Gloria Estrada & Viento Callejero

Susie Garcia & Las Colibri

Follow me on Twitter

RSS Alexa Blog

  • How to Optimize Your Content for B2B Lead Generation
    Website content is one of the most powerful tools for B2B lead generation. Digital content drives audiences to a webpage, informs and engages them, and converts them into qualified leads. Every page on a website should be created with lead generation in mind. Even if an individual piece of content does not include a lead […]
  • The Best Tactics for Long-Term SEO Results
    When it comes to long-term SEO strategies, there are so many tactics to consider. As outlined in a recent Alexa post, there are dozens of powerful marketing strategies to consider, and each comes with its own set of investments, risks, and rewards. With so many options, many brands and marketers are left to ask: What […]
  • Here Are 10 Buyer Persona Examples to Help You Create Your Own
    In a recent post, we looked at how you can create a buyer persona to help you get to know your audience, improve your marketing strategies, and create better content. We also offered a PDF buyer persona template you could use to develop your ideal customer profile. Now, we are going to dive deeper into […]
  • This Buyer Persona Template Will Help You Make Top-Quality Content
    While there are many best practices for creating content, there is one rule that will always be the most important: Know your audience. If you don’t know whom you’re talking to, it’s almost impossible to create powerful, targeted content that connects with readers and compels them to take action. The most effective strategic content is […]
  • The Complete Guide to Marketing Strategies: Risks, Rewards, and Investments
    When you sit down to create a marketing plan, it can be a little overwhelming. With so many marketing strategies to choose from, it can be difficult to pick the tactics that are right for your business. On top of that, not all marketing tactics are created equal. Some strategies require more investment, meaning [...] […]

RSS Search Engine Watch

  • Smart shopping season checklists: Mobile and desktop, content and SEO
    Constantly changing consumer behaviors and the demand for more personalized, meaningful experiences have retailers facing huge challenges this year. Competition in the ... read more
  • Black Friday SEO: Last-minute tips for the holiday season
    Black Friday kicks off a shopping season that lasts through Christmas each year, with online retailers vying for the profitable attention of consumers. With spending expected to rise by 47% this year, competition will be fierce. Some final tweaks to your SEO can make the difference between rising to the top of results and languishing […]
  • What factors should you consider before choosing a web crawler tool?
    SEO is a many-headed beast. From off-page elements to on-page elements, covering all aspects of SEO can easily become a Herculean task, especially when dealing with large websites. That is why a tool that crawls your website on a regular basis and brings back reports on what needs to be fixed is a must-have. What […]
  • Image optimization 101: How to rank higher in image search
    Optimizing images to rank well in search is a must for an increasingly visual web: a good logo or some eye-catching graphics can be as effective at attracting visitors to your website as your written content. But even if you're highly familiar with optimizing written content for search, you may not know where to begin […]
  • The ultimate guide to choosing keywords for ROI
    Keyword research is not easy. Every SEO has done it, but few will ever master it completely. In this guide we go beyond raw search volume data to metrics that will help you choose the keywords that deliver the best ROI for you right now.

RSS Search Engine Land

  • Search in Pics: Android candy dispenser, Google Jiu Jitsu shirt & Bing partner plaque
    In this week’s Search In Pictures, here are the latest images culled from the web, showing what people eat at the search engine companies, how they play, who they meet, where they speak, what toys they have and more. Happy Thanksgiving cupcakes: Source: Instagram Android candy dispenser:... Please visit Search Engine Land for the full […]
  • 2-step methodology for dealing with PPC performance downturns
    What happens when your paid search campaigns are experiencing a sudden and unexpected performance drop? Columnist Jeff Baum shows how to handle this situation -- without losing your clients' trust. The post 2-step methodology for dealing with PPC performance downturns appeared first on Search... Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article.
  • Coming to terms with fake reviews
    In the same way that Google considers some forms of SEO to be unacceptable, they and other review sites dislike any reviews that aren’t organic -- yet fake reviews are still prevalent. Columnist Kevin Lee discusses the scope of the problem and why you should resist the temptation to solicit fake... Please visit Search Engine […]
  • Thanksgiving Google doodle turkey pardons itself & takes leave from any dinner traditions
    “Unlike his domesticated brethren," writes Google, "the Turkey in today’s Doodle is taking flight…from the Thanksgiving table.” The post Thanksgiving Google doodle turkey pardons itself & takes leave from any dinner traditions appeared first on Search Engine Land. Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article.
  • SearchCap: Google printed materials, SEO migrations & development servers
    Below is what happened in search today, as reported on Search Engine Land and from other places across the web. The post SearchCap: Google printed materials, SEO migrations & development servers appeared first on Search Engine Land. Please visit Search Engine Land for the full article.

RSS Local Business Locator Blog

  • Did Fresno Police Chief Jerry Dyer Murder His Lieutenant?
      Did Fresno Police Chief Jerry Dyer Murder His Police Lieutenant – Jose Moralez?     Updated: November 2, 2017 after receiving new information. Official documents and evidence soon to be published on this site. More evidence and testimony set aside and reserved; NOT published herein.   Why do people believe that FRESNO POLICE CHIEF […]
  • CHAM (“Baby Cham”) in Association with Sevilla Local Media – “Money Wine” Release
        Sevilla Local Media, LLC (951) 289-1710 sevillalocalmedia@gmail.com www.sevillalocalmedia.com   For Immediate Release: Sevilla Local Media, a Riverside, California, based Digital Marketing & SEO Company that also manages and promotes a select stable of recording artists, announces an official association with CHAM (Damian Beckett), more famously known as BABY CHAM, specific to marketing, promotion […]
  • Richard Martinez of RISE PROGRAMS: True Love
      RISE PROGRAMS: www.riseprograms.com Featuring Richard Martinez LOVE SUFFERS LONG I have search and read many definitions of LOVE but the Bible to me has the best description of what love looks like. 1 Corinthians 13:4-8 “Love never gives up. Love cares more for others than for self. Love doesn’t want what it doesn’t have. […]
  • SEO Services – NO CONTRACT
    www.sevillalocalmedia.comMonthly SEO Services – NO CONTRACT – Affordable and Guaranteed ResultsSevilla Local Media Fact SheetA few facts about us:We operate on the following business philosophies: a. CUSTOMERS FOR LIFE (our client retention rate is above 95%) – we currently have SEO clients that have been with us since 2009 (Lu Granite + Roley’s Tree Care) […]
  • Help Support This Team – Donations Needed: Norte Vista High School Girls Golf Team
    GREAT CIGAR EVENTS Supports the Norte Vista High School Girls Golf Team!    The Norte Vista (“Novi”) Girls Golf Team is in their 2nd year of existence and self-supportive. They must pay for their gear, practices, league matches and all that is necessary to compete! Help take the burden off of these outstanding female student-athletes […]

RSS LBL Blogspot Feed

RSS Music Connection

  • Ringo Starr at Prudential Hall in Newark, NJ November 24, 2017
    Ringo Starr and his All-Starr band played the final show of their month-long tour at Prudential Hall (Newark, NJ) on Nov 16. This has been Starr’s longest running band which first toured in 2012. The band is selected and there is no audition process. The only requirement is to have had at least 3 hit […]
  • Lori Bell & Ron Satterfield - blue(s) (8/10) November 23, 2017
    Celebrating a 25-year partnership that has run parallel to their multi-faceted solo careers, veteran SoCal jazz greats Lori Bell (flute) and Ron Satterfield (guitar, vocals) apply their virtuosity to an intimate and soulful, rhythmically diverse and improvisation-rich landscape grounded in the blues. Satterfield’s acoustic lines and Al Jarreau-like voicings provide perfect harmony and counterpoint to Bell’s often graceful, always dynamic and joyfully […]
  • Signing Story: Sara Serena November 23, 2017
    Nineteen-year-old Spaniard Sara Serena began her sojourn to stardom two years ago when she auditioned online for Aim2Fame, a web-based singing competition. The show was not unlike a combination of American Idol meets Big Brother. When Serena’s audition video made the top sixteen, a spark was ignited. But when she went on to win, that […]
  • Peter Manning Robinson at the Vortex Dome in Los Angeles, CA November 22, 2017
    Avant-garde pianist/composer, Emmy award-winning composer, and instrument inventor Peter Manning Robinson played the Vortex Dome in Downtown L.A. on Nov. 11.  The award Winning set and project designer, and UCLA alum Hana Kim collaborated with Robinson on the visuals. Photos and Text by Alex Kluft The post Peter Manning Robinson at the Vortex Dome in Los […]
  • IAMA Finalist Jeff Gutt becomes new lead singer of Stone Temple Pilots November 22, 2017
    Jeff Gutt, a finalist at the 9th Annual IAMA and runner-up on X-Factor USA, has just been confirmed as the new lead singer for Stone Temple Pilots. The group, which scaled the heights of stardom in the 1990s, has seen its fair share of internal strife -- particularly the firing of frontman Scott Weiland in […]

RSS Political News

  • Woman Sits Down for Tea, Looks Out Window, Sees Freak Invasion of Own Town November 24, 2017
    A 61-year-old grandmother was enjoying her Sunday morning with a cup of tea when she looked out the window and saw that dozens of cows had completely taken over her town. According to U.K.’s Metro, Janis Wilson said she saw 30 to 40 of the bovine beasts roaming around the streets in her town of Bollington,… […]
  • Former Jihadist Scorches Islamists With 1 Suggestion for Their Everyday Lives November 24, 2017
    This is a message from a former jihadist that terrorists around the world should have been listening to. According to Fox News Insider, former radical jihadist Mubin Shaikh appeared on Fox and Friends in August 2017 after the 2017 terror attack in Barcelona, Spain, that killed 13 innocent people and injured more than 100 others. When… […]
  • Woman Who Attacked Bus Driver With Disgusting Bodily Fluid Just Got Bad News November 24, 2017
    A woman who threw a cup of her own urine on a Washington, D.C., bus driver now faces jail time. According to The Washington Post, Opal Brown pleaded guilty in early November to misdemeanor assault and was sentenced to 120 days in jail along with three years probation. This all stems from an incident that took… […]
  • Trump Thanks God, the One Word Obama Refused to Say November 24, 2017
    For many years, Thanksgiving Day has seen the sitting president of the United States issue a “National Day of Thanksgiving Proclamation” marking the holiday. This year was no exception. President Donald Trump issued his Thanksgiving proclamation, but there was a big difference between his and President Barack Obama’s 2016 proclamation, Myra Adams wrote for BizPac… […]
  • Marine Helicopter Touches Down in Soccer Field After Phone Turns Up Missing November 24, 2017
    The Marines made an epic retrieval after one of them left his phone at a Bar Harbor, Maine, restaurant on Saturday. As the tale goes, according to the Mount Desert Islander, six Marines ate lunch at the Thirsty Whale that afternoon. Later on in the day, server Jess Witherell says she got a call with the ID… […]
Please wait...

Subscribe to our newsletter

Want to be notified when our article is published? Enter your email address and name below to be the first to know.
%d bloggers like this: